Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions.
|Country:||Bosnia & Herzegovina|
|Published (Last):||14 December 2012|
|PDF File Size:||14.26 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||5.51 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Henshall Charles E. Tuttle, ISBN As a result, I often consulted this trusty guide, looking for information and inspiration. Henshall's guide is a serious and thorough work of scholarship. Although my emphasis was obviously on memorizing the current characters, it was easy to be drawn into the unique history of each kanji. In terms of creating stories, I felt it would be helpful to get a "feel" for each kanji and how it evolved.
Another idea was get as close to the "real" roots as possible with my stories. However, in many cases, this wasn't feasible and I ended up with a story totally unrelated the history of the kanji.
I submit this is not necessarily a bad thing, given the actual origins sometimes don't provide a lot of help in memorizing the modern characters, which I discuss next. In terms of memorizing kanji, this guide's biggest strength is in a real sense also its greatest drawback. That is, historical accuracy obliges the author to report on what a character, or piece of a character, was in the past -- even if that is of no use in memorizing the kanji in its current incarnation.
This is information overload -- it provides no assistance in memorizing the current kanji, although it is an interesting detour. Henshall concedes this in a sense, stating, "it may be useful to take it as such" i. The above is clearly a useful and effective mnemonic.
As a result, I would suggest that, unless you have a compelling reason to know the etymology of the kanji, you would be better served to first read the mnemonic, then just enough of the explanation to understand how it was put together.
This technique is quicker, and doesn't burden your memory with what is in fact non-essential information. Otherwise, you may find that you are actually memorizing a series of defunct kanji in order to remember a single modern kanji. This is like studying every Latin or Greek word which preceded the modern one to understand English-- too much work and unnecessary as well.
There is a further complication, even if you subscribe to the technique of limiting yourself to the mnemonics and a brief check of the explanation. Due to the derivation from historical origins, there are often similar interpretations given to different elements of a given kanji, or "primitives" as Heisig labels them. The mnemonic offered is "Four hands provide help".
This is nice and simple, but when recollecting the kanji, you must recall to which of the multiple versions of "hand" the mnemonic refers-- which brings you back to relying on raw memory. This is the main reason why I chose the Heisig system for memorizing kanji, which makes a point of being consistent in terms of assigning a single meaning to a single primitive.
Its keyword is "Abet" in the Heisig system, and it consists of the primitives "finger, claw, one, friendship", or more succinctly "finger, migrating ducks".
Keep in mind, of course, that you can always change the story-- but not the history. Which system works better? This is clearly up to the individual, and the two aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. For me, Henshall's guide fits in nicely as a companion for study under the Heisig system, providing rich background material and ideas for the stories you create on your own. The following information is provided for each kanji in Henshall's guide:. To sum up, this book is a superb study of kanji, meticulously researched, concisely explained, and elegantly presented.
I personally used it extensively for inspiration when creating my own stories, but in its own right it can be tremendously useful for remembering the kanji. Just be cognizant of your goals when perusing this book -- that is, you probably want to learn kanji as opposed to the history of kanji-- and orient your study accordingly. Previous Columns. Book Reviews. Other Articles. Reader Response.
Guide to Remembering Japanese Characters
Henshall Charles E. Tuttle, ISBN As a result, I often consulted this trusty guide, looking for information and inspiration. Henshall's guide is a serious and thorough work of scholarship. Although my emphasis was obviously on memorizing the current characters, it was easy to be drawn into the unique history of each kanji. In terms of creating stories, I felt it would be helpful to get a "feel" for each kanji and how it evolved. Another idea was get as close to the "real" roots as possible with my stories.
Learn Japanese - JapanesePod101.com
Henshall (1005 kyōiku kanji)